Few trends have divided fashion insiders quite like the so-called “granny sandal.” Defined by its sturdy straps, sensible heel, and unmistakably practical design, the style—championed by brands like Scholl, FitFlop and The Row—has oscillated between ironic cool and outright rejection. But now, Taylor Swift may have just settled the debate.
Spotted in New York’s West Village for a dinner outing with Ashley Avignone, Jack Antonoff and Jerrod Carmichael, Swift delivered a masterclass in context-driven styling. Her look—a shin-grazing striped midi dress by Staud—leaned fully into a polished, almost nostalgic femininity, offset by a sunshine-yellow Dior Lady Dior bag, famously named in honour of Princess Diana.
On her feet? A pair of Christian Louboutin “Her in Roma” sandals—complete with block heels, rounded toes, and sensible ankle straps. In other words: the very definition of the “granny sandal.”
What makes Swift’s take so compelling is its refusal to rely on irony. Where others have styled similar shoes with micro-minis or deliberately clashing pieces, she leans into their inherent conservatism. The result feels intentional rather than tongue-in-cheek—less trend-chasing, more character study.
It’s a notable pivot at a time when Christian Louboutin’s signature sky-high stilettos are enjoying a resurgence, embraced by a new generation of It-girls including Addison Rae, Jesse Jo Stark, Sabrina Carpenter and Gabbriette. Yet Swift’s choice suggests a quieter kind of confidence—one that prioritises cohesion over spectacle.
If the question was whether “granny sandals” can truly work, Swift’s answer is clear: they can—provided the rest of the outfit speaks the same language.
